- Solutions
- Company
Introduction
Artificial intelligence has made remarkable progress in various domains, from mastering strategic games like Go to enabling self-driving cars and creating today's advanced language models. One area that has captured significant attention is Deep Reinforcement Learning (Deep RL), especially after DeepMind's landmark achievement of teaching robots to autonomously play soccer. However, while Deep RL excels in simulated environments with rapid feedback, it encounters major limitations when applied to the real-world complexity of industrial systems. Enter Causal AI, a promising approach that can overcome these challenges by focusing on understanding cause-and-effect relationships rather than relying solely on trial-and-error learning.
The Rise of Deep Reinforcement Learning in Robotics
DeepMind's successes with Deep RL in robotics highlighted its potential. Through trial and error, robotic agents learned sophisticated strategies, like playing 1v1 soccer, outperforming traditional pre-programmed systems. This success relied heavily on the ability to simulate millions of scenarios rapidly, allowing the agents to identify optimal strategies through continuous feedback. Each time a robot kicked a ball or missed a goal, feedback was instantaneous, enabling the system to quickly adjust its policy—the decision-making framework guiding its actions.
This quick feedback cycle is key to Deep RL's effectiveness in robotics. The state space—the set of all possible conditions the robot could face—was also relatively manageable. Feedback came rapidly, and the results of an action could be directly linked to the system's next decisions.
The Complexity of Industrial Systems
Contrast this with large-scale industrial settings, such as manufacturing plants. The complexity here is orders of magnitude greater, involving thousands of variables and interactions. Critically, feedback is often delayed. For instance, the quality of a product batch might only be known after hours or even days of testing, making it difficult to adjust in real-time.
Moreover, industrial environments present problems that are not always solvable with trial-and-error approaches. Running millions of simulations to account for every possible combination of factors is impractical. Delayed feedback and complex dependencies make it difficult to trace a poor outcome back to the exact decisions or variables that caused it, limiting the effectiveness of Deep RL. In these environments, the lack of immediate feedback and clear cause-and-effect pathways poses significant challenges.
Delayed Feedback and the Limits of Deep RL
A core limitation of Deep RL in these settings is its reliance on timely feedback to optimize decision-making. Reinforcement learning excels when an agent can receive immediate returns (rewards or penalties) for its actions, allowing it to update its policies quickly. This is much harder in industries where the "returns" (i.e., the outcomes of actions) are delayed by long processes or only revealed after extensive testing. Furthermore, industrial systems often have hidden variables and complex causal structures that make direct trial-and-error learning inefficient or even hazardous.
To handle delayed returns, techniques like Q-learning—which updates value estimates based on the difference between expected and actual returns—help, but only to a limited extent. Deep RL still struggles in systems where simulations are expensive or impractical, and where outcomes cannot be immediately linked to actions.
Introducing Causal AI and Structural Causal Models
This is where Causal AI comes into play. Rather than relying on trial and error, Causal AI focuses on understanding the cause-and-effect relationships within a system. It uses Structural Causal Models (SCMs), which are mathematical frameworks built from observational data, to model the interdependencies between variables. These models go beyond mere correlation, providing insights into how changes in one part of the system impact others.
By capturing the causal mechanisms at play, Causal AI can predict the outcomes of different actions even when those outcomes are delayed or indirect. This ability is crucial in industrial systems, where one adjustment might affect not only immediate performance but also long-term quality, efficiency, or equipment health.
Self-Supervised Learning and Virtual Sensors
Causal AI also incorporates advanced techniques like self-supervised learning to enhance its predictive power. In industrial settings, some variables are difficult or time-consuming to measure directly, but virtual sensors can estimate these variables in real-time. For instance, in a paper manufacturing process, a virtual sensor might predict moisture content based on other easily measurable factors, enabling proactive adjustments.
By combining these predictive models with causal reasoning, Causal AI optimizes policy decisions in a way that considers all operational constraints and objectives. It allows for the determination of optimal control points—such as temperature or pressure settings—that simultaneously optimize quality, efficiency, and risk mitigation.
Why Causal AI Outperforms Deep RL in Industrial Settings
The key difference between Deep RL and Causal AI lies in their suitability for different environments. Deep RL is designed for scenarios with immediate feedback and manageable state spaces, where millions of simulations can be run to refine policies. In contrast, Causal AI is built for environments with delayed feedback, complex interactions, and limited opportunities for trial and error. It uses existing data to model systems and reason about the consequences of actions, making it far more practical for large-scale, real-world applications.
Moreover, by modeling causal relationships explicitly, Causal AI can handle unknown causations more effectively. It doesn't require retraining from scratch when new data becomes available; instead, it can update its models to reflect newly observed patterns and causal pathways. This adaptability makes Causal AI more efficient in dealing with dynamic industrial environments.
Real-World Impact and Future Prospects
The application of Causal AI to industrial control systems has transformative potential. By optimizing complex processes and reducing waste, it enables companies to improve product quality and minimize costly production errors. As industries become more data-rich and complex, the need for AI systems that can navigate this complexity and make reliable decisions becomes even more critical.
Companies like Vernaio are at the forefront of this transformation, helping industries harness the power of Causal AI in their operations. By implementing practical Causal AI solutions, manufacturers have seen significant improvements in their production efficiency, with some reporting up to 75% reduction in quality-related issues and substantial energy savings. These real-world implementations demonstrate that Causal AI isn't just a theoretical concept—it's a proven solution for today's industrial challenges.
Looking ahead, the success of Causal AI in these industrial contexts points to its broader applicability in areas like healthcare, finance, and large-scale logistics. By focusing on causation rather than correlation, Causal AI offers a more explainable and trustworthy approach to AI-driven decision-making.
Conclusion
While Deep Reinforcement Learning has garnered significant attention for its success in robotics and gaming, its limitations become evident when applied to complex real-world systems like industrial manufacturing. Causal AI offers a more viable solution, leveraging the power of causal reasoning to tackle the unique challenges of delayed feedback, complex dependencies, and large state spaces.
As AI continues to evolve, it's crucial to select the right tools for the task. For industrial systems, Causal AI doesn't just offer an alternative approach—it provides a solution that could reshape the future of manufacturing and beyond.
